Similar Posts

17 Comments

  1. Love hearing your tips on raised beds, I am slowly transitioning to all raised beds, I love that I can sit on one while weeding in another! Thank you for sharing your post on Our Simple Homestead Blog Hop, as one of the co-hosts I will be featuring your post tomorrow!
    – Nancy Nancy On The Home Front

  2. Raised beds are a great solutions when you only have rock as we do for landscaping. I can plant almost anything in them. Congratulations on being featured on Nancy on The Home Front!

    Stop by if you have a chance on the #OMHGFF this week!

    Have a great week!
    Karren

  3. Hey Girl,

    I am currently living in Florida but was born and raised on the cape. This is an excellent idea for building a garden! Thanks for the inspiration.

  4. So excited to have found your blog and these tips!! I also saved your blog on the $5 trellis.
    Thank you for sharing and now that I’ve found you, I look forward to following you here and on social media!

    1. Any bed made out of wood will eventually rot, but I have found that with the untreated pine I still get about 7 years out them

  5. Why is it everything else I read on earth says pure compost is bad. Yet you are saying never use topsoil. Everything else on earth says to use 50% topsoil 50% compost.

    On top of that your missinformation about treated lumber, please do your research before making educational articles. Your plants won’t uptake arsenic unless it is starving for potassium, you are using compost, this is not a problem.

    1. In the 15 or so years I have been using raised beds I have never added topsoil to them, so i am sharing my experiences. Pure compost is not “bad”, and neither is mixing topsoil & compost. Topsoil is great for helping the soil hold its water and not dry out as fast which is why many people mix it with compost in their beds. Topsoil is also added because it is stronger so it won’t compact as quickly, leaving the bed less than full. I will clarify my statement, when I said “don’t use topsoil”, I meant don’t use it 100% to fill the bed. Your vegetables will not get the nutrients they need. I look at raised beds as really large pots. When you are growing a lot of plants in a pot or confined space (especially vegetables that use a lot of resources) they need a lot of nutrients. The garden section of my blog is aimed at people growing vegetables, and often in tight spaces which requires really rich soil. When gardening like this you will need to water more often because of the large amount of plants, and the depleted soil in the bed will need to be topped off each year. This works for annual vegetables as your new crop of plants each spring will have fresh rich soil. It would not work well if you are growing perennials whose roots would be disturbed by the shrinking soil in the bed. I realize not everyone reading my posts individually is familiar with my blog on a whole, so I will update the post to be more clear. Thank you for the feedback.

      As for the treated lumber, I feel my post was already clear, that modern treated lumber is not treated with arsenic. I advised against using old, salvaged treated lumber because it is treated with arsenic and even though I am using compost and test my soil, not everyone will. Why would you want to risk that? My main issue with modern treated lumber is that it is treated with copper which can stunt or kill plants in excessive amounts. I admit in the article that pine boards are not a permanent solution. They will rot eventually, but they won’t kill your plants & are inexpensive

  6. Good job Liz. And please ignore the morons that think treated lumber and toxic materials next to growing veggies are a good idea, it’s not a good idea and you are spot on with your choice to use inexpensive pine.

    I’ve also seen people use cinder blocks and those are made from coal ash and industrial waste and are never a good idea (some claim the toxic stuff is all locked up in the concrete but concrete leaches in moisture and raised beds are moist). I also shy away from plastics because those leach as well.

    Your pine beds are logical, non toxic, attractive, inexpensive, decent longevity for the buck, and a perfect project to tackle with my 5 year old son. Thank you.

    1. You are absolutely right, I wrote this article in 2016. Lumber prices are outrageous right now! I will have to update

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.